Winchester SX4 VS A300 Ultima | WAS I WRONG!? | Shotgun Showdown

shotgun showdown Nov 11, 2021

Ladies and gentleman - I may have been wrong about my shotgun showdown selection between my SX4 and the A300 Ultima. The SX4 has been my main work house out in the field and on the range for many years now. I know it inside and out and have shot tens of thousands of rounds through it doing live exhibitions. The Ultima was a brand new gun that I was excited to get my hands on. During my Ultima review, I shot a 1.12 which was my fastest time ever - until now.

In a recent video, I beat that time with my brand new SX4 (CHECK IT OUT HERE) I have also been getting a flood of comments and messages saying that people were having troubles with their Ultima. So I went out to shoot with some buddy's and my Ultima started having similar troubles. Mainly the trigger locks up, the safety wont budge, and some shells just won't cycle. With that said, todays video is all about reflecting on why I chose the Ultima, and deciding whether that was the right choice. SPOILER ALERT I think I was definitely wrong for choosing the A300 Ultima. Here is a quick breakdown from the previous shotgun showdown

The Ultima has an MSRP of $899; The SX4 has an MSRP of $829; But you can find both of these guns competitively priced at Reeds:

(Shop the Ultima at Reeds)

(Shop the SX4 at Reeds)

Quick Specs

Winchester SX4

12 gauge
3" chamber (also available in 3.5")
28" Barrell (also available in 26")
7lbs
Length of Pull 14 1/4" Out of the Box (adjustable with included spacers)
Drop at Comb 1 3/4" (Adjustable with provided shims)
Drop at Heel 2"

Beretta A300 Ultima

12 gauge (also available in 20 gauge)
3" chamber
28" Barrell
7lbs 10oz
Length of Pull 14 1/4" Out of the Box (adjustable with included spacers)
Adjustable cast and drop

Ergonomics/Look & Feel

Winchester SX4

Feels great in the hands - might be my bias, but I love the feel
Very light and easy to maneuver
Forearm grooves are solid
Hard plastic synthetic feels got for the value
Oversized charging handle and bolt release for easy operating
Large trigger guard - If you're going to be shooting with gloves on, the trigger guard had plenty of room.

Beretta A300 Ultima

Very nicely balanced in the hands
Trigger guard is not oversized - I prefer large trigger guards
Not used to the overall feel yet, grips are not as solid
Oversized charging handle and bolt release for easy operating - huge improvement over the A300 Outlander
Pistol grip is a bit wider than I prefer
Love the oversized charging handle and bolt release; very smooth - the bolt release is very soft and easy to utilize
Reversible cross-bolt safety in front of the trigger - I prefer rear mounted safety's

Trigger

Winchester SX4

5lbs 3oz (Average)
Crisp trigger - basically no travel. Feels great!

Beretta A300 Ultima

4lbs 13oz (Average)
Has more travel than I'd like. Feels spongy
Very light relatively speaking - wish it was more crisp

Quality of Build

Winchester SX4

I always look at the quality of the build relative to the price. Everything on the SX4 comes together nicely and is tight
Hard synthetic all around. Controls are durable
Run of the mill materials - great value at this price point
Forearm has just a bit of looseness - nothing detrimental

Beretta A300 Ultima

What both of these shotguns are known for is being durable workhorses - I think the Ultima lives up to the durability of my tried and tested SX4
Also hard synthetic all around - receiver is metal and looks and feels very nice
Very nice tolerances - all around super solid
Milled out loading port along with nice receiver give the A300 an edge in my books.

Ease of Breakdown

Winchester SX4

Simple to break down for a full cleaning. Again, I've cleaned this gun many times

Beretta A300 Ultima

Very simple to break down for a gas gun.
Love the one pin design to take of the trigger group
The components are tighter being that the gun is brand new, but once it breaks in, the Ultima is easier to breakdown

Recoil - This was the toughest comparison. Both guns are incredibly light

Winchester SX4

For years I've said that the SX4 is the lightest recoiling 12 gauge - that statement still stands

Beretta A300 Ultima

This gun sports the Kick-Off recoil reduction system and claims 70% reduction
No problems whatsoever when shooting 3" Target loads from the shoulder, recoil is among the lightest shotguns I have shot.
I'm not totally sold yet on the two stage recoil impulse - although it did make choosing a winner very difficult

Reliability

Winchester SX4

What can I say, the SX4 has been my go-to for years now - ultra reliable

Beretta A400 Extreme Plus

Didn't cycle super consistently right away over the head - I'll be gracious being that it's brand new
Has a bit of muzzle jump from the shoulder

Speed Shooting

Winchester SX4 (UPDATED!!!)

I just picked up my brand new custom SX4 - I won't spoil the time... but check out the video (HERE)

Beretta A300 Ultima

This gun impressed me. In the Ultima review I was able to crush 3 clays in 1.12 seconds, and it didn't take me long to get there. This is one of my fastest times, and I just couldn't beat it today with the SX4 - I'm very impressed

In summary, this was a tough comparison to make considering my long and tested history with the SX4. The SX4 is still my go to and continues to be an ultra-reliable, fast shooting, solid gun.