Picking out the right gun
Good morning everyone,
I’m looking for some community input to help select a dedicated upland shotgun that bridges two very different states and environments: Wisconsin (wild pheasants, ruffed grouse, and preserve/farm chukars) and Georgia (wild bobwhite quail).
Previously, I’ve hunted with a Stoeger M3000 12-gauge. While it is a reliable firearm, it is heavy for all-day walking and has proved to be overkill on close-flushing birds like bobwhites and farm chukars.
I’m currently cross-shopping three specific models:
- Beretta A400 Upland 20 Gauge (Standard or KO / Kick-Off)
- Beretta A400 Upland 28 Gauge (Standard or KO / Kick-Off)
- Franchi Affinity 3 Upland (Inertia)
My core dilemma: I want a nimble, lightweight setup that won't punish my joints on long walks or tear up delicate birds at 15–20 yards, but still has enough payload capacity and pattern density to cleanly anchor late-season wild Wisconsin roosters at 35–40+ yards.
For those hunting multiple species across similar covers, what gauge and model would you recommend as the ultimate 'one-gun' solution for this specific mix? Any insights, choke strategies, or field experiences would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!
I believe your most versatile choice is the 20 gauge…ammo is easier to find and cheaper. Payload is potentially higher for more pellets down range.
I had a similar dilemma, looking for a shotgun to use for multiple pursuits…ended up purchasing a Benelli Ethos 20 gauge over the A400 upland. I just liked how slim and light it was.
I’ve used a 28 gauge (over/under) for quail, dove, and sporting clays. I’ve been surprised by how well it shoots and the birds fold at some pretty good distance. They are a really fun gun to shoot, albeit, I’ve yet to choose it for pheasant over my 20, for payload reasons. If I’m paying for a guide service to take me on a pheasant hunt, I’d like to put the bird on the dinner table 😀
If you want one gun to cover it all, of your list, I would choose the A400 20 gauge.
I use Carlson Cremator Mid Range most of the time. Takes ducks, geese, pheasants no problem. For Quail, I like Improved so I don’t destroy them.
I have both the A400 Upland in 20 & 28. I would go 20 for the range and cheaper ammo. The 28 is awesome but also is great for a challenge... I am not the best shot, but is still fun for sure. Definitely lighter and no kick, but honestly the 20 is pretty light and I don't feel much kick either.
Daylen, I’m an absolute big fan of the 28 gauge, but with what you’re describing, the 20 gauge seems like the more sensible option, especially for pheasants. 28 gauge ammo is also quite a bit more expensive. That said, if you absolutely love shooting a 28, that counts for something too.
Of the guns you listed, I’d personally go with the A400 Upland 20 gauge over the Affinity 3.
A couple of others worth a look:
- Budget option: the Retay Gordion is outstanding.
- More refined option: the Benelli Montefeltro Silver Featherweight is a great choice.
I would go with the 20ga as well, and the same as everyone has said about the 20 ga ammo.
I would also look at the Weatherby 18i limited its in the price range of what you are looking into.
The 20ga will never blow apart birds like a 12ga will, The choke would be a after market choke from Carlsons, or Briley a mod or Light full and play the different shot sizes