Skip to main content

The third option?

It's time to upgrade my shotgun and I thought I had it narrowed down to two, the maxus 2 or a400 solo. I wanted a light recoiling gas gun that would be 60/40 waterfowl vs upland/clays. Then I had a thought...what if I instead spent $1000 dollars on the gun and $1000 on custom work or upgrades. Could someone turn a SX4 into a better gun than the Maxus 2 for a similar price? Are there any platforms that this works well with? I do this often with bolt action rifles but I don't know enough about what's upgradeable or available for shotguns. Thanks for any feedback.

Brian Willing

Rob Roberts Custom Gunworks does this work. You can browse his webpage for pricing and examples of the work.

Jake x

Thanks Brian, this was a good resource! Okay here's a hypothetical option #3

SX4 hybrid hunter upgraded with:

Falcon Strike pad

RR (Rob Roberts) Forcing cone elongated

RR trigger work

RR parts polishing

RR "Slam Button"

Muller choke

Including shipping this takes it to ~$1800

So if you could pick one and why

Maxus 2

A400 Solo

Upgraded SX4

Brian Willing

Jake x 

I own the SX4 hybrid Hunter in 20 gauge. It’s fantastic and I really don’t see a lot of need to do upgrades, it’s already a great stock setup for waterfowl. It’s been dropped, Cerakote has been scratched in the blinds, but it still shoots great and a great tool for hunting. My son has taken a liking to it and he now uses it for waterfowl and clays.

I’m not sure a falcon strike is even needed for the SX4. The recoil pad is really good and doesn’t snag on the clothes. Perhaps elongating the forcing cone might give slightly better patterning… but I’m not convinced you will really notice real world advantages in paying for elongated forcing cone.

You could always buy the SX4 with a good aftermarket choke. Shoot it a bit, and decide later if you need the upgrades. SX4 already has an enlarged bolt release button and a pretty decent trigger. The "looks" of the RR upgrades are definitely pretty sweet...

Ed Ducote

The Beretta A400 line of guns already has the best barrel dynamics in the industry including a very elongated forcing cone. I would take that off the list of upgrades as well as any after market recoil pad.

Jake x

Ed Ducote Thank you Ed for the reply. I wouldn't be doing any upgrades to the maxus or a400. My question is could you upgrade/customize a SX4, Mossberg 940, etc... and have a better shotgun for similar money as the stock maxus 2 or a400?

Ed Ducote

Jake x Short answer, I certainly don't see how. Factory set gun vs upgrade/customizing, hoping it will satisfy you. But that's my opinion.

Maybe it's just me but, why not buy a gun that has the factory features you need vs sending a lesser gun to be customized. Spend the money up front for factory quality and warranty.

I don't know your age or how much money you have, but after spending many years on this earth I've learned that it was better for me to save, wait, and buy what I really wanted/needed vs buying the lesser and trying to modify it to suit me. But, that scenario may not fit your station in life.

Bottom line: Whatever you decide to do, the gun needs to produce whatever you desire it to and you have to like the gun. A gun that you like will always be a joy to shoot....have fun.

Jake x

Ed Ducote That's a good point about the warranty. I'm middle aged and it's not about the money. I build custom bolt action rifles...that was the thought behind asking. I start with the action and put on exactly the barrel, stock, and trigger I want on it. Now that Tikka threads their barrels I can buy the most budget T3x drop it in a premium stock or chassis and I have a better rifle, tailored to me, for less money than the equivalent high end Tikka model. I've been shooting the same Benelli Supernova for 20 years and haven't followed what's going on with shotguns the same way I have with bolt guns. From the feedback on the forum and research I've been doing it doesn't sound like it's the same thing for custom/ aftermarket shotguns. I'm leaning towards the A400 solo, but there isn't much for long term feedback on it yet.

Ed Ducote

Jake x 👍

Nathan Phillips

Buy the one that fits you the best. Fit is more important than a longer forcing cone or trigger work in my opinion. If it doesn’t fit it will hurt to shoot and you will not hit anything. After you make your purchase you can then upgrade if you feel like it will make an improvement.

Steve Gould

Interesting question. I know this is more common in the rifle world than the shotgun world, but you can do a lot to improve a shotgun's looks and performance. But to give you an honest answer, I had to first consider what I would do and really, at the end of the day, it depends on what you want. Some people love customization and they enjoy the process, others just want a good shooting gun and don't care. If you got and SX4 and did all the things you listed, do you have a better gun than say the A400? That's debatable. But the better question is did you enjoy building out your unique gun? Does it bring you joy? If the answer is yes, go that route. If you just want a great shooting gun, get the A400.