Skip to main content

12 Gauge vs 20 Gauge for Ducks and Geese

Are sub-gauge duck guns dead now that bismuth and tungsten cost so much? We put a 12 gauge vs 20 gauge head to head with steel shot and found the 20 still works, as long as you let the birds come in close. If you could only bring one gun and one load for a mixed bag of ducks and geese, what would it be?
If you could only bring one gun and one load for a mixed bag of ducks and geese, what would it be?

Watch the full video

Jamison Ogburn

Call me crazy, but I have been using 20-gauge Upland Steel #6s for the past two seasons and have LOVED them. I have noticed way less cripples and probably cut the number of shells I have to bring to the field in half. I don't take a rangefinder with me waterfowl hunting, but I'm sure many of these shots were around the 35-40 yard mark but usually backpedaling in the decoys. The reason I switched to 6s was a combination of price, and I felt like I was making good shots with #2s, but there seemed to be some gaps in my spread. Some birds would fall, some would be hit and fly off, and a significant number were crippled and would require follow-up shots. The smaller shot sizes have dramatically improved my shooting and have given me the confidence to open up my choke size, all while pulling the trigger less, and bagging more birds.

Steve Gould

Jamison Ogburn That is an interesting observation. What birds are you shooing? Any geese?

John Wiles

Jamison Ogburn Well written and thought out.

Jamison Ogburn

Steve Gould A few Canada geese but not enough to make any real observations good or bad compared to a 12-gauge. The ducks have been everything from teal to late season mallards in a blizzard here in Missouri. I also feel like a 20-gauge gives me an edge on speed to correct the path of my swing, and it is nice saving a little bit of weight, as I'm usually walking in a couple of miles to hunt. I definitely still use a 12-gauge some, but I far prefer my 20-gauge. One of my things though is I am picky about my setup and shots. I try to only shoot decoying birds, and try not to shoot at butts.

John Wiles

Okay, here's the old man weighing in. Do Bismuth, Tungsten Matrix, and Boss CuProX have more retainied energy at 40 yards than steel? Are you more likely to 'kill' the duck outright with these shells and cripple them with steel? Steel has made great improvements, and, yes, it really may be the answer, but the cost of the shells should NOT be the driving factor. How many shells do you shoot at ducks in a season?The limit is 6. You hunt every Saturday during the season. How many Saturdays is that? 8? 12? Okay, you shoot 30 days a season. How many limits do you shoot? 30? (Possession is 3 times the limit) But for math's sake, let's say you are a skilled caller, decoy setter, and fine shooter, and you take 30 limits, or 180 ducks. How many shells did you shoot to get 180 ducks. If you are good shooter, would you shoot 80%? The average is 5 shots per bird. Soooo, if you are 'average', you would shoot 900 shells to kill 180 ducks. Let's say you buy 4 'flats' at the opening of the season. That's 1,000 shells, 100 boxes at a cost of $55 per box, or $5500. Boss shells are $40 per box or $4000 for 1000 shells. That's significant and certainly cost prohibitive, when you can buy steel shells for $15 a box low end or $40 a box high end. At $15 a box, 1000 shells would be $600. No argument from this perspective that steel is cheaper, and it's becoming better as manufacturers ramp up to meet hunters' needs.

BUT, what if you are the 'average' duck hunter? You get out a half dozen times a year; you have one or two really good shoots during the season, but you go because of every other thing we say we love hunting ducks for, and killing is the ultimate reward. How many shells will you shoot in those outings? One box? Two boxes? Now you have spent $100 and you are confident you can kill a duck cleanly at 40 yards. Yes, you could have spent $30 on steel, too. Look at it from another perspective. How much did you shotgun cost? $1000? $1500? $2000? Your gunning bag? Waterproof, camo gear? Decoys? Call? Boots/waders? Boat? Gas? Time? What is one good day worth? What is one really great shot worth?

That one duck, circling high, about to leave, it's now or never. 40 yards you think, maybe less, maybe more. Can you kill it cleanly? Are you confident in your skill as well as your equipment? Is a $2 shell worth the memory of that great shot?

When we start checking our reality the cost of shells becomes relevant to how many we shoot and the situations we will be in. I spend $200 for good quality shells before the first duck hunt. I can always get more if I need to. Generally, I don't need to.

There are several stages in a Hunter's life - The Shooting Stage (I just want to shoot), the Limiting Out Stage (I'm going to stay until I get a limit), The Trophy Stage ( one good duck, one good double), Method Stage (Best set, know the wind, the terrain, the weather the species), Sportmans' Stage (Enjoying the coffee, the sunrise, and your friends more than pulling the trigger), 'Give Back' Stage (Lessons learned, safety, young people, the beauty in knowing that "the sum is more than the parts".

Where you are in those stages will determine what you spend on shells and a lot of other things as well.

Steve Gould

John Wiles John, you make some really good points here, and I appreciate you laying out the math. The "what is one great shot worth" angle is a fair way to look at it, especially for the guy who only gets out a handful of times a season.

The reality on the market side, though, is that tungsten is going away for a lot of manufacturers because the price has gotten outrageous, and bismuth is running around four dollars a shot. That's a tough pill for most hunters, even if they only shoot a box or two. You and I may see it differently, but that's just the reality.

There are a lot of people who aren't going to spend that kind of money, and with how far steel has come, they don't really have to. Pattern your gun, know your effective range, and pick your shots, and steel will get the job done cleanly.

Love the stages of a hunter's life breakdown too. That's a great way to frame it.

John Wiles

Steve Gould the stages aren't mine. I heard them years ago and now have lived them all.Your sentence "Pattern your gun, ... cleanly" says it all.

Brian Willing

I used a 20 gauge SX4 with Apex #2 @1250, paired with a Müller decoy choke, with good results on Canada Goose and mallards.

I do think I would prefer having a 12 gauge in the blind if geese are coming in. Having an extra 3/8oz steel shot #2 is quite a few more pellets.

Nathan Phillips

I purchased a 20 gauge a few years ago to use on waterfowl hunts because of the sub gauge craze. I have a few spots that if the weather and water levels are right the shots are only 20 yards. But with that said I still always grab the 12 gauge. The funny thing is I have been shooting 3 inch number 2 and 4 that are from the late 90s and early 2000s. I don't seem to have a problem, but I don't take long shots. I am sure premium shells are worth it, but I would rather spend my money on other items.

Ed Ducote

I've shot ducks/geese with both the 12 and 20 with #3 steel loads. The only difference is the density of the pattern as you reach the longer shots because obviously the amount of pellets decrease between the gauges. A #3 steel shot hits at the same strength no matter what gauge. With the 20, the pattern density thins more rapidly as it travels over distance because of the smaller load. But if you were to shoot a 1 ounce load in both gauges, you should see no difference in performance.

What I've found to be the real difference between the gauges is the inaccuracy of the shooter. If you are a so-so shooter, you might very well need the heavier 12 ga loads hoping that a bunch more pellets will cover the bird better. But if you put the load where it needs to be, you'll find that the 20 is just as deadly as the 12.

Considering the load and choke in any gauge is important so you can deliver a lethal shot string where the bird is going to be at impact.